"Run, Don't Walk"
Wall Street continues to focus on the idea that stocks are "cheap"...
As
I noted in our September 8, 2008 comment Deja Vu (Again), which
happened to be a week before Lehman failed and the market collapsed,
"Currently, the S&P 500 is trading at about 15 times prior peak
earnings, but that multiple is somewhat misleading because those prior
peak earnings reflected extremely elevated profit margins on a
historical basis. On normalized profit margins, the market's current
valuation remains well above the level established at any prior bear
market low, including 2002 (in fact, it is closer to levels established
at most historical bull market peaks). Based on our standard
methodology, the S&P 500 Index is priced to achieve expected total
returns over the coming decade in the range of 4-6% annually." Present valuations are of course more elevated today than they were before that plunge.
On the economic front, the recent uptick in new unemployment claims
is consistent with the leading economic measures and "unobserved
components" estimates that we obtain from the broad economic data
here...
As I noted a few months ago, "examining the past 10 U.S.
recessions, it turns out that payroll employment growth was positive in 8
of those 10 recessions in the very month that the recession began.
These were not small numbers... while robust job creation is no evidence
at all that a recession is not directly ahead, a significant negative
print on jobs is a fairly useful confirmation of the turning point,
provided that leading recession indicators are already in place."
The
upshot is that while I expect a weak April jobs report, we should
hesitate to take leading information from what remains largely a
short-lagging indicator. We're already seeing deterioration in economic data, but it remains largely dismissed as noise.
An acceleration of economic deterioration as we move toward midyear
would be more difficult to ignore. My impression is that investors and
analysts don't recognize that we've never seen the ensemble of broad
economic drivers and aggregate output (real personal income, real
personal consumption, real final sales, global output, real GDP, and
even employment growth) jointly as weak as they are now on a year-over-year basis, except in association with recession. All of these measures have negative standardized values here. My guess is that we'll eventually mark a new recession as beginning in April or May 2012...
What I am adamantly against is the idea that speculators can successfully
"game" overvalued, overbought, overbullish markets - particularly in
the face of numerous hostile syndromes, near-panic insider selling,
speculation in new issues, and broad divergences in market internals, all of which we are now observing.
Read Hussman's entire economic commentary here.
