Joining Russia, China, and Brazil now is India in questioning the value of their Dollar reserves:
NEW YORK (MarketWatch) -- A senior official in the Indian government has joined the growing chorus questioning the U.S. dollar's unofficial position as global reserve currency, according a report published Saturday.
Suresh Tendulkar, chairman of the Prime Minister's Economic Advisory Council, said he's urging India to diversify its foreign-exchange reserves and hold fewer dollars, according to Bloomberg News.
Tendulkar said the fact that India holds so much of its reserves in dollars "is a problem for us," reported Bloomberg.
Tendulkar's comments come one week after the People's Bank of China's annual financial stability report repeated an earlier call by central bank chief Zhou Xiaochuan for the development of a new super-sovereign currency that would largely take the place of the dollar.In early June, an official at The Bank of Russia reportedly said it will cut the share of U.S. Treasurys in its foreign exchange reserves.
Alexei Ulyukayev, first deputy chairman of Russia's central bank, said the bank plans to reduce the amount of Treasurys and that Russia would switch some of its reserves into bonds issued by the International Monetary Fund, according to reports.
Also on Saturday, China Daily reported that former Chinese Vice-Premier Zeng Peiyan in a speech in Beijing on Friday called for a new system to ensure the stability of the major reserve currencies. Zeng is the head of China Center for International Economic Exchanges.
Under the existing reserve currency arrangements, there needs to be tighter controls because "your currency is likely to become my problem," said Zeng, according to China Daily.
The rhetoric towards the dollar's international status comes as leaders of the world's leading economies ready to meet in Italy for the G8 Summit 2009, which will be held from July 8 to July 10. The heads of Canada, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Russia, U.K. and U.S. will gather in L'Aquila, and discussions of ways to improve international finance are on the agenda.
Representatives from China, India, Brazil, Mexico, South Africa and Egypt will also be present at the meeting.July 6 (Bloomberg) -- Russia and India said the world economy is too reliant on the U.S. dollar and called for changes in how $6.5 trillion in currency reserves are managed, as Group of Eight leaders prepare to meet this week.
“The dollar system or the system based on the dollar and euro have shown that they are flawed,” Russian President Dmitry Medvedev said in an interview with Corriere della Sera, repeating his proposal for a new international reserve currency.
Suresh Tendulkar, an economic adviser to Indian Prime Minister Manmohan Singh, said in a July 3 interview that he is urging his nation to diversify its foreign holdings away from the dollar.
The challenge to the dollar, a linchpin of world finance and trade since 1945, underlines the shift in relative economic power toward emerging markets and away from the developed nations that spawned the global crisis.
French Finance Minister Christine Lagarde, speaking yesterday at a conference in Aix en Provence, France, said that “we must explore better coordination of exchange-rate policy.”
Questions need to be asked about “the balance of currencies and the role of currencies in a world that has changed because of the crisis and the growing role of emerging countries,” she told reporters.
Bank of France Governor Christian Noyer said at the same conference, “We really need to make sure there is a greater stability between the big currencies in the period to come.”
Dollar Share Grows
For all the concerns about the dollar’s role, emerging markets such as China and India remain dependent on the currency. The International Monetary Fund said June 30 the share of dollars in allocated global foreign-exchange reserves increased to 65 percent, or $2.6 trillion, in the first three months of this year, the highest since 2007.
China doesn’t support the idea of creating a supranational reserve currency and expects the U.S. dollar to maintain its role for “many years to come,” Deputy Foreign Minister He Yafei told reporters in Rome yesterday.
While Medvedev said he sees “no alternative” to the dollar or euro now, he repeated his proposal that “regional reserve currencies” be developed and again questioned the wisdom of relying on the dollar.
‘Cannot Be Hostages’
“In the long term, we must also think about a single unit of payment such as the International Monetary Fund’s Special Drawing Rights,” a unit of an account linked to a basket of currencies, he told the Italian newspaper. “We cannot be hostages to the economic situation of a single country, as is happening today with the United States.”
Russia has support. India’s Tendulkar said he is advising Singh to diversify India’s $264.6 billion in foreign-exchange reserves and hold fewer dollars.
“The major part of Indian reserves are in dollars -- that is something that’s a problem for us,” he said in Aix en Provence. He said big dollar holders face a “prisoner’s dilemma,” a reference to a problem in game theory in which a rational choice for an individual has negative consequences for a group.
The People’s Bank of China, that country’s central bank, said June 26 that the IMF should manage more of its members’ reserves. China said July 2 that it will allow companies to use the yuan to settle cross-border trade and let them keep their entitlement to export tax rebates, seeking to reduce the reliance of importers and exporters on the U.S. dollar.
Safe Haven
The dollar’s role as a safe haven was highlighted last week when the currency advanced 0.5 percent against the euro, to $1.3894, on speculation the global economic recovery is faltering.
“Some emerging countries have decided to deal more in their respective currencies and trust each other,” Lagarde said in an interview yesterday. “That doesn’t stop other countries from seeing the dollar, and to a lesser extent the euro, as currencies of trading if not reserve currencies.”
Lagarde said that any discussion of currencies needs to encompass the dollar, the euro, the yuan and the yen and that the meetings of the Group of 20 are the right forum.
“The appropriate platform is the one in which all the major currencies are represented,” she said.
Asked in Aix en Provence about currencies, European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet said it is “extremely important” that U.S. officials remain committed to their policy of supporting a strong dollar.
